Arc Forumnew | comments | leaders | submitlogin
3 points by conanite 5176 days ago | link | parent

Two problems with (o arg default) - you need to remember not to use 'o at the start of a destructuring list (and not get confused when you see (def handle-request ((i o ip)) ...) ), and as akkartik says it's paren-inefficient, a single keyword to delimit required/optional args would mean fewer tokens.

The first problem is easy to fix though - use a symbol that's less likely to be an arg name to identify optional args. How about '= ?

  (def myfun (a b (= c (something)) ...)
it has the advantage of similarity with ruby:

  def myfun a, b, c=something
disadvantage: looks silly when you don't supply a default value:

  (def myfun (a b (= c) ...)